Scaling a Toy Brand: 200+ New Stockists & Top Shop Status
The Brand
A high-quality Montessori Wooden Toy brand dedicated to creating beautiful, educational playthings. While they were registered on Faire, they had zero traction and no clear roadmap for growth. Furthermore, they had recently rebranded and wanted to make sure everything was done right from the ground up. The owners wanted to focus on their "zone of genius" designing new collections and building the brand rather than learning the technicalities of marketplace algorithms from scratch.
The Challenge: The "Cold Start" Problem
Despite having a world-class product, the brand was essentially invisible to retailers. Before partnering with Sona, they faced several hurdles:
Zero Initial Momentum: They were registered but hadn't seen any traction or consistent order flow.
Low Social Proof: They started with a 4.8 rating and only 4 reviews, which made larger boutiques hesitant to commit.
Missing Top Shop Status: When we began, the brand did not have the Faire Top Shop badge, missing out on the vital search boost and "trust signal" that the platform's most successful brands carry.
The "Activity Gap": Like many founders, the owner didn't realize that Faire isn't "set it and forget it." He wasn't aware of the need for daily platform activity, building direct relationships with retailers, or how to leverage Faire’s marketing tools like segmented newsletters and direct messaging to stay top-of-mind.
The Lead Generation Misconception: He didn't know that one of the fastest ways to trigger the Faire algorithm and grow is by adding new leads to the platform and driving them through Faire Direct.
The Technical Barrier: The founder didn't want to spend months learning "Filter SEO" or how to manage a digital storefront while also managing global production.
Our Strategy: Building the Engine
We acted as their complete, outsourced wholesale department, moving the brand from a quiet listing to a high-conversion engine through a scaling plan.
Ground-Up Optimization: We built the storefront from scratch, optimizing SEO keywords and titles for "High Potential" products to dominate organic search, while continuously updating keywords and refreshing collections every season, even though the brand mostly features non-seasonal products.
Review-Driven Momentum: Through proactive, personalized follow-ups, we grew their social proof from a handful of ratings to 52 total reviews with a perfect 5-star average, creating an "authority moat" while building long-term relationships to maximize long-term customer value.
Advanced Paid Listings: We leveraged Faire Promoted Listings to acquire new customers and retargeted "window shoppers," resulting in a 4.4x blended first-year ROAS, acknowledging that while our strategy is primarily organic and doesn't rely heavily on promotions, paid listings serve as a great-to-have auxiliary tool.
3-Sequence Outreach System: We utilized CRM tools outside of Faire to find brand-aligned leads, adding hundreds of Faire retailers to our cold Klaviyo flow every month. We introduced the brand via a 5-part email sequence using their Faire Direct link (0% commission) and strategic sample offers to remove the barrier to entry, while also building comprehensive Klaviyo flows including a welcome flow, reorder flow, and flows for lapsed customers, all combined with weekly newsletters on Klaviyo and personalized, targeted newsletters sent directly through Faire.
Bestseller & Communication Amplification: We highlighted their fast shipping and excellent communication, turning operational efficiency into a marketing asset that built immediate retailer trust, while leveraging their top shop badge to reinforce the trust earned from previous customers.
The "Win": 2.4x Revenue and Securing the Top Shop Badge
By offloading management to us, this US kids' toy brand transformed from a dormant listing into an elite-level performer, achieving an incredible 137.14% revenue growth.
2.4x Order Surge: We scaled the brand from virtually zero traction to a thriving, high-volume wholesale operation.
Achieving Top Shop Status: By scaling the review count to 52, maintaining a flawless 5-star rating, and optimizing response times, we secured the prestigious Faire Top Shop badge for the brand, instantly supercharging their visibility and building deep trust with previous customers.
Strategic Reorder Growth: We implemented a high-touch retention system to ensure long-term profitability. By using Faire customer segmentation to identify buying patterns, we deployed targeted newsletter campaigns, built advanced Klaviyo flows (including welcome, reorder, and lapsed-customer sequences), and sent personalized direct messages that nurtured existing retailers, turning one-time buyers into loyal, consistent reorder accounts to maximize lifetime customer value.
Rapid Retailer Acquisition: We successfully added over 200 new retailers within 6 months while continuously adding hundreds of potential new stockists to their cold pipeline every month. We introduced the brand to these prospects using their Faire Direct link (0% commission) paired with strategic sample offers to seamlessly remove any barriers to entry.
Efficiency at Scale: We maintained an impressive 45% newsletter open rate, proving that our segmented approach resonated deeply with their audience. This was further elevated by custom-designed templates that replaced the standard, uninspiring Faire layouts.
Increased AOV: Through thoughtful catalog curation, seasonal collection refreshes (even for non-seasonal products), and strategic launch support, the Average Order Value (AOV) successfully grew to $350.
Hear From Our Client
“Working with Jutta and Sona Wholesale has been a genuine pleasure and a strategic win for our business. Jutta and her team are sharp, competent, and deeply committed to our growth. After years of dealing with agencies that over-promise and under-deliver, Jutta has been a breath of fresh air. From day one, she has been transparent, honest, and relentlessly focused on our bottom line. I look forward to a long, productive partnership with Sona Wholesale Consulting.” - Mike, Owner
Long-Term Relationships over Transactions
Beyond the numbers, our strategy focused on building a sustainable business. By using personalized onboarding messages and segmented reorder campaigns, we ensured that new retailers didn't just buy once, they became long-term partners.
"We didn't just give them a presence on Faire, we gave them a scalable business. By taking them from zero to Top Shop status, we allowed the founder to focus on what they do best: creating the next generation of Montessori toys." — Jutta, Founder of Sona Wholesale Consulting
Ready to make your brand the next success story?
Let’s turn your Faire Store into a high-growth engine.
💬 Book your Free Discovery Call Today
